- Understand the concept of good debt vs bad debt
- Learn how to evaluate debt decisions
- Know when borrowing can be a smart financial move
- Recognize predatory lending practices
Not All Debt is Created Equal
Most people think all debt is bad. That's not quite right. The key question is: What is the debt doing for you?
- Good debt helps you build wealth or increase earning potential
- Bad debt finances consumption that loses value immediately
Characteristics of Good Debt
Good debt typically has these features:
What Makes Debt "Good"
-
Builds an asset or increases value
The thing you're borrowing for goes UP in value over time
-
Increases earning potential
It helps you make more money in the future
-
Has low interest rates
Typically below 6-7% APR
-
Often tax-deductible
Mortgage interest and some student loan interest
Examples of Good Debt
Mortgage (Usually Good)
- Real estate historically appreciates over time
- Low interest rates (3-7% typically)
- Interest is tax-deductible (if you itemize)
- Builds equity instead of paying rent
- Fixed payment while rents increase
Caveat: Can become bad debt if you buy more house than you can afford.
Student Loans (Can Be Good)
- Education increases lifetime earning potential
- Often lower interest rates than other debt
- Some interest is tax-deductible
- Income-driven repayment options available
Caveat: Becomes bad debt if you borrow $100k for a degree leading to a $35k/year job.
Business Loans (Can Be Good)
- Capital to start or grow a business
- Potential for significant returns
- Interest is a business expense (tax-deductible)
Caveat: High risk if business fails. Research and plan carefully.
Characteristics of Bad Debt
Bad debt typically has these features:
What Makes Debt "Bad"
-
Finances things that lose value
Cars, electronics, clothes, vacations
-
High interest rates
Credit cards (15-25%+), payday loans (400%+)
-
No tax benefits
You can't deduct consumer debt interest
-
Creates no future value
You're paying for past consumption, not future gains
Examples of Bad Debt
Credit Card Debt (Almost Always Bad)
- Average APR: 20-25%
- Usually finances depreciating items or consumption
- Minimum payments keep you in debt for decades
- Compounds quickly - $5,000 can become $10,000 fast
Auto Loans (Usually Bad)
- Cars lose 20-30% value in year one
- Average new car payment: $700+/month
- Long terms (72-84 months) mean years of payments
- Often "underwater" (owe more than car is worth)
Better approach: Buy reliable used cars with cash, or small loans you can pay off quickly.
Payday Loans (Always Bad)
- APRs of 400% or more
- Designed to trap you in a cycle of debt
- Fees eat up most of your next paycheck
- Never, ever use these - there's always a better option
The Gray Areas
Some debt isn't clearly good or bad - it depends on the situation:
Context Matters
Good if consolidating high-interest debt at lower rate. Bad if financing a vacation.
Good if you have the cash but want to keep it invested. Bad if you couldn't afford it otherwise.
Sometimes unavoidable. Negotiate payment plans and ask about charity care.
Questions Before Taking on Debt
Before borrowing, ask yourself:
- Will this increase in value or help me earn more?
- What's the interest rate? Below 6-7% is generally acceptable.
- Can I comfortably afford the payments? Include in your budget.
- Is there a cheaper alternative? Buying used, waiting, saving up?
- What happens if my situation changes? Job loss, emergency?
- Interest rates over 36% (most consumer advocates' threshold)
- "No credit check" loans
- Pressure to sign quickly
- Balloon payments at the end
- Excessive fees or prepayment penalties
- Rent-to-own stores (often 100%+ effective APR)